Aperture compared with other NVRs
This page compares Aperture with five other network video recorders: what each runs on, what it costs, how it detects objects, how you use it from a phone, and how it connects to Home Assistant. It ends with who should pick which. Aperture is not the right choice for everyone, and the last section says when.
Facts about the other products come from their own documentation and websites, read in November 2026. A cell that says “not checked” is something that could not be confirmed there. Prices and features change; follow the links on the pages for each product.
Platform, license and cost
Section titled “Platform, license and cost”| Runs on | License and cost | |
|---|---|---|
| Aperture | x86-64 Linux with systemd. The installer targets Debian and Ubuntu. Not ARM, Windows or macOS. Installed as native systemd services. | PolyForm Noncommercial 1.0.0. Free for personal and other noncommercial use; commercial use needs a separate license. Source-available, not open source. |
| Frigate | A Docker container on any Docker host, or a Home Assistant App. Runs best with Docker on bare-metal Debian-based Linux. Windows is not officially supported. The documentation also covers Raspberry Pi and Rockchip boards. | MIT. Free. Cloud services such as Frigate+ are optional. |
| Blue Iris | Windows 10 or 11, 64-bit. | Paid license: $99.95 for up to 128 cameras, $39.95 for one camera. One year of basic maintenance is included; extending it is listed at $44.95 a year. A free demo can be downloaded. |
| UniFi Protect | A UniFi console (Cloud Gateway, Network Video Recorder or Cloud Key+) with storage disks. Ubiquiti does not offer Protect for self-hosting on other hardware. | No license or subscription fee. You buy the console, the storage and, usually, UniFi cameras. |
| ZoneMinder | Linux packages for Ubuntu, Debian, Red Hat and Fedora, Docker images for amd64 and arm64. macOS and Windows 10 or later (through WSL) are documented too. | GPL version 2. Free. |
| Viseron | Docker only. Images for amd64, aarch64 and armhf, with variants for CUDA, the Raspberry Pi 3 and the Jetson Nano. | MIT. Free. |
Object detection and hardware
Section titled “Object detection and hardware”| How objects are detected | |
|---|---|
| Aperture | Built in and local: YOLOX and D-FINE models in ONNX Runtime, on the CPU or an NVIDIA GPU from Pascal to Blackwell. Off until you turn it on. AMD GPUs are detected but not used. A Coral or similar chip helps only through an external DeepStack or CodeProject.AI style server. Finds people, vehicles, animals and delivered parcels. See Object recognition. |
| Frigate | Built in and local. The documentation lists detectors for Hailo, Google Coral, Intel OpenVINO, NVIDIA GPUs (through ONNX), AMD ROCm, Apple Silicon and Rockchip, plus community-supported ones. It says a detector is strongly recommended and CPU detection is for testing only. Optional features include semantic search, face recognition, license plate recognition and bird classification. |
| Blue Iris | AI services are built in since version 6.0.1 (December 2025). Its website also lists external CodeProject.AI and Blue Onyx servers. The recommended specifications list an optional NVIDIA graphics card. |
| UniFi Protect | AI runs on UniFi’s own cameras: person and vehicle detection, and face and license plate recognition on AI or G6 series cameras. Third-party ONVIF cameras get motion detection, PTZ control and audio only. |
| ZoneMinder | Motion analysis is built in. Object, person and face detection comes from a third-party Event Notification Server with machine-learning hooks, which the ZoneMinder documentation describes. |
| Viseron | Built in: object detection, face recognition and license plate recognition. Its site says it supports CUDA, Google Coral EdgeTPU and Jetson Nano, among others. |
Phones and remote access
Section titled “Phones and remote access”| Phones and remote access | |
|---|---|
| Aperture | An iPhone app (free, iOS 18 or later, needs Aperture 1.4 or later) and a web app for every phone. There is no Android app; Android uses the web app. You set up remote access yourself, with a VPN or an HTTPS reverse proxy. Notifications to the iPhone app pass through Aperture’s push relay, encrypted so the relay cannot read them. See On your phone. |
| Frigate | Web interface. Notifications use web push (HTTPS required) or Home Assistant notifications. The Frigate apps found on the App Store come from third parties. You expose Frigate yourself; the documentation has a reverse proxy guide. |
| Blue Iris | Its own iOS and Android apps, and a built-in web server for desktop and mobile viewing from outside your network. |
| UniFi Protect | The Protect mobile app for iOS and Android, and UniFi Site Manager. Remote access is an encrypted connection brokered through Ubiquiti’s cloud to the local console; footage stays on the console. Remote access is optional and free. |
| ZoneMinder | The web console works on a phone. zmNinja is a third-party app for iOS, Android and desktops; it needs ZoneMinder’s API installed. |
| Viseron | Not checked. |
Cameras, Home Assistant and recording
Section titled “Cameras, Home Assistant and recording”| Cameras | Home Assistant | Recording | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aperture | Any RTSP source. You add each camera by address; there is no network scan. ONVIF is optional, for picture settings. UniFi Protect cameras come in for live view. | Aperture is the camera source and publishes to Home Assistant over MQTT discovery. Nothing is installed in Home Assistant. | Copies the camera’s stream without re-encoding. Re-encoding to a lower quality is a per-camera option, on the CPU or an NVIDIA GPU. |
| Frigate | The documentation recommends cameras with H.264 video, AAC audio and several streams. | An official integration, installed through HACS. Needs MQTT. | Written from the camera stream without re-encoding. |
| Blue Iris | Up to 128 cameras: USB cameras, network IP cameras, analog capture cards and the Windows desktop. | No built-in integration page on home-assistant.io; the Home Assistant forum documents community integrations and MQTT setups. | Not checked. |
| UniFi Protect | UniFi cameras, and third-party ONVIF cameras with limited features. | A built-in Home Assistant integration. Needs a UniFi OS console running Protect 7.2.105 or later. | Records to the console. Enhanced Retention lowers the quality of older footage to save space. |
| ZoneMinder | Monitors from IP cameras, local devices, files and web pages. | A built-in Home Assistant integration. | Video Writer either re-encodes the stream or records the camera’s H.264 as it is; JPEG frames are an option. |
| Viseron | Not checked. | Publishes Home Assistant MQTT discovery. | Not checked. |
Which one to choose
Section titled “Which one to choose”Aperture
Section titled “Aperture”- You have an x86-64 Linux machine, or can set one up, and want one installer rather than a container stack.
- You want object recognition on the CPU as a supported path, with an NVIDIA GPU as an upgrade, and have no Coral.
- You use an iPhone and want an app made for the server.
- Your use is personal or otherwise noncommercial. The license does not allow commercial use without a separate agreement.
It has limits that matter to some people: x86-64 Linux only, no Android app, no support for Coral, Hailo, Intel or AMD accelerators in its own recognition, and a young project with a small community. See Aperture vs Frigate for the closest comparison.
Frigate
Section titled “Frigate”- You want the widest choice of detector hardware, an ARM board, or an MIT license.
- You want features Aperture does not document, such as semantic search, face recognition or license plate recognition.
- You want the largest community and the most users to ask for help. Aperture is new and its community is small.
See Aperture vs Frigate.
Blue Iris
Section titled “Blue Iris”- You run Windows, want a commercial product with its own iOS and Android apps, or need USB or analog capture cameras.
UniFi Protect
Section titled “UniFi Protect”- You want an appliance with cameras from one vendor, on-camera AI including faces and license plates, and Ubiquiti’s own apps and remote access.
See Aperture vs UniFi Protect.
ZoneMinder
Section titled “ZoneMinder”- You want GPL software on many Linux distributions or in Docker on ARM, a built-in Home Assistant integration, and a multi-server install.
Viseron
Section titled “Viseron”- You want an MIT-licensed, Docker-based recorder with Coral, CUDA or Jetson support and face and license plate recognition.
Related
Section titled “Related”Aperture vs Frigate · License · Requirements and sizing · FAQ